For months, I was deliberating whether or not to purchase some Sugarpill. Could I justify it, given that I own a monster Inglot palette full of brights?
Click here for swatches of my Inglot palette.
We all know how this story ends- I purchased the Sugarpill Burning Heart Palette and Lumi Pigment on CameraReadyCosmetics, along with materials for pressing Fyrinnae Pigments (tutorial post in the making).
Now, I rarely mention packaging, generally I have little opinion on the subject. But really, Sugarpill, what is this?
Why is there a cat on my palette? Paired with a cross? And a crown? So many unanswered questions. Undeniably ugly.
Upon opening the palette, my faith was redeemed. The four shades included in this quad are as follows:
– Flamepoint, a vibrant matte primary orange
– Buttercupcake, a vivid matte primary yellow
– Love+, a true red that doesn’t lean orange nor pink. Although it may appear to be a matte, it does have a slight sparkle similar to the Inglot DS line.
– Poison Plum, a rich violet shade with pinkened undertones. Same finish as Love+, matte base with almost undetectable sparkle.
Also, a picture of Sugarpill Lumi Pigment in the pot. You may be able to detect that the white shimmer has a teal gleam, depending on the lighting. Nikkietutorials introduced me to this and I think it will be a unique inner corner highlight.
My review of the colours, pigment and texture at the end of this post. Firstly, swatches!
Left to right: Love+, Poison Plum, Buttercupcake, Flamepoint, Lumi Pigment (partially over a black base)
In the interest of being ultra thorough, each shade in the quad compared to similar counterparts in other brands.
Sugarpill Love+, Inglot 382, Inglot 366, Inglot AMC 50
Sugarpill Poison Plum, Inglot 320, Inglot 325, MAC Grape Pigment
Sugarpill Flamepoint, Inglot 383, Orange from Sleek Paraguaya Palette
Yellows (um…why do I only own two yellows?!)
Sugarpill Buttercupcake, Inglot 323
My opinion on this palette is mostly positive but marred by one aspect; my Love+ pigment and texture is pretty horrid. The product is very hard and required a lot of rubbing to obtain a decent swatch. It’s such a pity because it is the perfect primary red shade; in comparison my Inglot 382 & AMC 50 look fuschia and the Inglot 366 looks peach.
I spoke to others that own this palette and many reported that they had the same issue but with different colours, this leads me to think that Sugarpill may have a quality control issue and this will deter me from buying another palette from them in the future. I emailed CameraReadyCosmetics to determine whether there is a remedy but I have not yet received a response.
Ranting aside, the other shades in this palette have magnificent pigment and texture, slightly harder than the Inglot but none of the powdery characteristics associated with some Inglot eyeshadows.
I preferred the Sugarpill shade in every comparison picture shown above;
– Love+ was my only ‘true’ red shade
– Poison Plum was the brightest of my purples, with a delicious pink undertone that lends that bruise-y look that I love (I’M WEIRD)
– Flamepoint was indisputably the most vibrant orange
– Buttercupcake prevailed over the Inglot 323, which has a white base that can sometimes appear powdery.
In case it wasn’t clear, I’m very pleased with three out of four eyeshadows in this palette and I think I’ll get great use out of them! A look is coming soon!
Any of my readers own Sugarpill? What are you thoughts? Did you experience any problems with pigment or texture?
Want more makeup reviews and tutorials?
Get new posts and updates delivered straight to your inbox!